Friday, 18 November 2011

Protected Conversations - Carl Fender - Barrister at Regency Chambers

Is the Government's alternative to compensated no-fault dismissals really worth the candle? Having decided to drop this idea, the alternative of 'protected conversations' is to be put out for consultation. The CBI supports the proposal. The idea amounts to 'without prejudice' discussions about an employee's performance in the workplace, and preventing what has been said being used against the employer in, for instance, a constructive dismissal claim. This proposal is just one of several ideas being considered to free our employment laws of so-called red tape.

One does wonder if what is driving reform of our employment laws is more perception than reality. Employers are quoted as being fearful of expensive and time-consuming litigation as a result of dismissing poorly-performing staff. The existing legislation around dismissals for capability is couched in terms of reasonableness. Employers running their businesses efficiently should be able to demonstrate whether or not employees are meeting required standards in performance. The raising of the qualifying period for bringing an unfair dismissal claim to 2 years should be enough reassurance for employers if they feel our present laws disincentivise recruitment.

Although the detail of any proposed legislation has yet to be finalised, one can see much satellite litigation resulting from what is/is not a 'protected conversation'. Reducing claims to the tribunal is another aim of the raft of reforms that are going through or are under consultation. Will the number of claims being presented reduce because of this particular proposal? An impact assessment already sees a reduction because of the raising of the qualifying period. Others see litigants using discrimination or automatic unfair dismissal grounds where they are time barred. It is certainly arguable that whilst 'protected conversations' might provide some immunity to employers in respect of particular occasions when discussions occurred, they are unlikely to encourage conciliation or loyalty. An employee who has had the Riot Act read to them, and who knows they cannot immediately resign, is hardly likely to feel valued or incentivised to work. 

Tuesday, 15 November 2011

The Law of unintended consequences - Nigel Sleight - Barrister at Regency Chambers

The Law of unintended consequences

Last week I was involved in a very difficult final hearing involving parents arguing about residence...my client was represented the other side in person. During the hearing a number of things became clear as to the effects of the planned cuts to Legal Aid. Some of course are the more obvious which have been well documented e.g. Increasing the length of court hearings but a number of other things became clear:

1. Neither side would be eligible for Legal Aid in the case yet equally neither would have been able to afford any kind of expert assessment which happened to be vital in this case to help understand the needs of the child. What does the court do in those circumstances?

2. A way around for the problem above is for the court to appoint more Guardians under R16.4 and for the experts to be paid for on the legal aid certificate of the child - thus just transferring costs not saving them and meaning the appointment of more Guardians to try and assist the courts between parents.

3. Those cases that will in the future not have the assistance of legal representation are also likely to result in more professionals involved in cases e.g. Social workers - being called to give evidence as it will be less likely the parents (for very obvious and natural reasons) will be able to do without their evidence as they feel they will have to explore every issue so they do not feel disadvantaged - not necessarily upon what the key issues in case may be.

I'm sure there are many more.....

Thursday, 10 November 2011

Change to qualifying period for unfair dismissal claims - Carl Fender - Barrister at Regency Chambers

As part of the Government's drive to cut red tape for business and encourage growth in the economy, there is to be a rise in the qualifying period for brining a claim for unfair dismissal.  It is currently 1 year, a period the employee must have worked continuoulsy for by the effective date of termination.  From the 6th April 2012, that period will return to 2 years, the level it was until 1999 when New Labour lowered it to its current position.  The new legislation will amend the law as stated in s.108 of the Employment Rights Act 1996.  There are no proposals to alter the right to claim automatic unfair dismissal on other protected grounds, where there is no qualifying period.

The qualifying period has changed over the years since its inception in 1971.  It was initially 6 months, reaching 2 years in 1985.  It has been the subject of litigation as well because previous rules on qualifying thresholds for part-time workers were found to be indirectly discriminatory against female workers.  However, a challenge to the earlier 2 year period in R v Secretary of State for Employment ex p. Seymour-Smith, after a legal journey all the way to the House of Lords, then Luxembourg and back, ultimately failed.

It could be said that this is not really about cutting red tape per se. The rule was simple to apply whatever the length of the qualifying period.  Encouraging employers to take on more employees by deregulating the early phase of employment as well as reducing the number of claims presented to the Employment Tribunal is what this proposal is all about.  This is just one of a number of proposals, each of which have their own time-scale.  There are proposals in respect of introducing a basic fee structure for tribunal claims, for example, as well as other measures to speed up the tribunal process.  The Government's consultation document, published in January 2011 sets them out.  Arguments against implementation are partly based on a battle of statistics.  There are also fears that disqualified claimants will simply re-locate their claims within the discrimination legisltation.  Whatever the opposition, the Government is intent on driving through business friendly measures to stimulate the economy.

Monday, 7 November 2011

Public/Press Awareness - Nigel Sleight - Barrister at Regency Chambers

Public/press awareness....

Over the past few days there has been an awful lot of commentary on the Famiy Justice Review and what it may mean in practice. Some of the more emotive headlines such as 'Grandparents denied access rights' are clearly misreported. Firstly they have not been denied any such 'right' in the review rather it has stated that it does not make any recommendations to alter the existing law which would already allow a grandparent to bring an application for contact or residence with the leave of the court.

The comments made on a number of articles that have appeared in the paper [e.g. by Joanne Edwards appearing to today's Observer:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/nov/06/legal-aid-families-joanne-edwards?newsfeed=true]

show how varied the responses are to the two key issues of the moment i.e. reforming family law and the cutting of legal aid. The inherent tension between the Governments aims is clear but it is also the case that these implications are being missed by the wider public. By way of example (and it is purely ONE example) many fathers are writing that they are disappointed the Review did not make a recommendation for 50:50 care of children when couples separate yet at the same time are pleased legal aid for such disputes is being severely curtailed (on the basis it is women who are more likely to qualify for Legal Aid).

However two huge things seem to be constantly overlooked:

1. The same father who is accused of domestic violence will himself not be eligible for Legal Aid to defend himself against allegations (irrespective of their means)

2. Any father being forced to bring a contact/residence application will have a much longer ride through the courts clogged up with litigants in person!

Friday, 4 November 2011

"It's Just Not Cricket" - Gareth Jacques - Barrister at Regency Chambers

For my second post of the day, I thought I'd comment on one of the days biggest news pieces, and a sport very close to my heart.

The sentencing took place today of 3 Pakistani cricketers and a sports agent for match fixing. The 4 men appeared before Mr. Justice Cooke, at the Southwark Crown Court for sentencing following a lengthy trial of 3 of the Defendants which culminated in guilty verdicts being delivered on Tuesday. (The agent having plead guilty at an earlier hearing).

The charges stemmed from match fixing allegations with regards to the 4th Test Match of the summer 2010 series of England v Pakistan. An undercover reporter for the News of the World filmed the sports agent, Mazhar Majeed predicting exactly when 2 Pakistani bowlers would bowl no balls and collecting 150,000 GBP in cash as a result of the prediction.

The bowlers found to be guilty of bowling the no balls were Mohammed Amir and Mohammed Asif. The trial had heard that the chances of someone correctly predicting when 3 no balls would be bowled was around 1.5 million to 1.

The team captain at the time, Salman Butt was also found guilty of match fixing, as he was paid to ensure that the correct bowlers were bowling at the right time.

Sentencing all 4 defendant's to immediate custody, Mr. Justice Cooke said:

"The image and integrity of what was once a game but is now a business is damaged in the eyes of all, including the many youngsters who regarded you as heroes and would have given their eye teeth to play at the levels and with the skills that you had".

Salman Butt was sentenced to 30 months in prison, Mohammed Asif 12 months, Mohammed Amir 6 months and Mazhar Majeed 32 months.

As Mr. Justice Cooke remarked "It's not cricket" - and it's certainly hard to disagree.

Family Justice Review - part 2 - Nigel Sleight - Barrister at Regency Chambers

It's fine in theory....

Reading through the family justice review in more detail this afternoon I noticed that one of the key aims of better judicial case management was to give the judges more reading time of the papers. For those of us at the coal face we are all too aware of how the Judiciary don't have enough work to do, how the DJ's complain all the time about quiet s8 lists where no-one is waiting to see a CAFCASS Officer. How fortunate we don't have an ever increasing number of litigants in person. No doubt the governments timing of withdrawal of Legal Aid and cutting fees to experts (note to self: must start search again for a paediatric radiologist tomorrow who will work at the new LSC rates!) is all part of some master plan to help the smooth implementation of the proposed reforms.....

Being serious though the FJR highlights the lack of clear research/evidence on various aspects of the proposals it makes. On the issue of the recent expert rates set by the LSC I would be interested to hear the experience of other people so far in getting experts to undertake the work.

Thursday, 3 November 2011

Family Justice Review released today - Gareth Jacques - barrister at Regency Chambers

Thursday, 3 November 2011

Family Justice Review released today - 3/11/11

My first post, and on a day when I can actually post something interesting!!

The final report of the Family Justice Review was released this morning.

Will this be good for Family Law as a whole? My guess is we will have to wait and see.

The key "headline grabbing" points seem to be:

  • A recommendation to "bin" residence and contact orders, but replace them with "Child Arrangements Orders."
  • A new two track system for family cases should be implemented "simple" and "complex" - and the level of Judge needed for the case will be determined on the cases track allocation.
  • A new Family Justice Service will be established which is to be responsible for the budgets of court social work services, mediation, out of Court resolution services and it is thought that in time it will be responsible for budgets in relation to the instruction of experts and solicitors for the children.
  • The same Judge should have conduct of the case all the way through.
  • A single Family Court system should be set up where all levels of the judiciary sit in the same building (i.e. Magistrates, DJ's and CJ's)
  • The High Court will remain for complex cases, but High Court Judges are going to be encouraged to travel to the single Family Court point to hear their cases.
  • In all but exceptional caes, Care Proceedings must be concluded within 6 months of them commencing.
  • Experts will only be instructed in cases where their involvement is necessary to conclude the case, and the impact of delay to the child (when instructing an expert) should be considered even more than it currently is.
  • A new online hub for starting divorce proceedings will be established.
  • Parents will be encouraged to resolve disputes regarding their children outside of Court.
 The full report can be found at:

http://www.justice.gov.uk/downloads/publications/policy/moj/family-justice-review-final-report.pdf
My thoughts on the report to follow soon...